Club Reviews: WE ARE ALL WEIRD by Seth Godin
Saturday, December 17, 2011
In a word - Weird: The idea that the forces of individuality (the Weird in all of us) are on the rise seems reasonable and is a very convincing explanation in theory, to the reactions many feel to the mass distribution solutions and monoculture copies of products that used to be made locally with quality.
The push-back to a power of individual expression and “weird power” has some limitations though, and may not be original enough to overcome the restraints imposed upon what’s come to be called “your brand”; the conventional expression and communication method.
Even the chaos of spontaneous evaluation by internet feed-back, that Godin and other gurus favor, (cue Al Gore’s – Assault on Reason book here) may not be enough to antidote the case made by mass managed sales of “what is normal”; that pushes us to conformity.
The truth of the product evaluations that we can “dig for” on the internet, can be so obscured by the economic force of the marketing machine, that your shopping choices are not getting to the consumers equally, let alone guaranteeing equal access to the products that result.
It can be very time consuming to sort it all out. The thing missed in Godin’s case to “Get ready for the “weird”; is not so much that the product or idea sells itself, but that the marketing tipping point is dictated by the realities of convenience (as well as price and other concerns) that makes the sale. We have a hard time joining a group consensus that is under-represented in real time or time zones away.
When convenience is factored in, the educated consumer may not be given the time to make honest choices. The minority “weird” solution is just too inconvenient. Look at all the plastic, so-called disposables, that we settle for, only to throw away; is this because to select the alternative weird idea as a way to problem solve (say go green) wouldn’t be practical? And even more so, the weird would fail so fast, if it meant fighting the “wired consensus” that defines a norm or conformity. So we do the best with the givens, the common denomintors i.e. the normal solutions; because convenience is worth plenty, and it sells. Jim Swaner, Miami Shores, FL
This book takes a look at how mass marketing worked through the medium of television and radio in the 1950’s and 60’s, and then through example shows us how that kind of marketing isn’t working as well today. In the fifties and sixties everyone watch the same TV shows and listened to the same ‘Top Forty’ radio shows and mass marketing to the people who fit into the ‘normal’ on a bell curve worked.
Today everyone wants to ‘live’ their dream, be it some obscure cultural thing or just to let their ‘freak flag wave’. The internet has certainly been a driving force where anyone can find a group, or as Seth calls them a ‘tribe’, that anyone call associate with.
Therefore businesses that want to reach those people have to market to them specifically.
My favorite quote in the book: “Everyone hates advertising in general, but we love advertising in particular”. Tom Hinz, Blue Lake, CA
Particularly us baby boomers and those who came after us. Being different and being out of the box made our generation and the ones that followed even more. Marketing today is finding niches and doing them well. Some niches will remain just that but others will find a tipping point that takes them to being the next "apple". Good read for anyone coming out of business school or thinking of starting a business to get them to sit down and think what markets are not being targeted and creating business models to fulfill those markets.. Paul Bartoletti
This book grabbed my attention from the beginning. Made me think about how much I really need in the way of outside things. I realyzed how sucked into he mass I had become and realized it's okay to be weird and have my own likes, dislikes, and opinions. This well written book has brought an awareness of my surroundings when shopping and helped me make wiser buying decisions.
The world goes full circle. Seth Godin remarks that before the Factories and Mass Production, there were small tribes and communities where everything was nearby. Mass has allowed us to expand beyond those small communities.